- This post is for members of BlueandGold only. Join now! 30-Day Free Trial
jiggafini19
- 5 stars Rating: 89
1828 votes total - (3303)
- 30 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
mgormal1 said...
I've actually taken some heat for posting this over on II, but I've seen the kid play several sports over the years. I think his ranking is too high. The league he plays in often gets confused with Don Bosco, Bergen Catholic, St Joes', etc because they are close to each other but the league is nowhere near that caliber and they definitely don't play the big boys and the good parachials. I know, cause I played in it. Good football, good coaches, but rarely does it produce d-1 talent. He is definitely a d-1 talent but he isn't playing against other d-1 talent.
Two, as a QB, this the project of all projects. I realize this comes off as overly negative but I really cannot see how he could play QB in college at any place other than GTECH. It would have to be some dramatic metamorphosis in terms of mechanics, arm strength, understanding of defenses. He has none of those things even close to being a college QB right now. I've seen people compare him to Golson, in terms of being a QB they couldn't be further apart.
Another thing I didn't like is that he wasn't a varsity basketball player last year. He spent time on the JV, and really didn't impress there. I mean if you are a legit D-1 athlete that can play corner, safety, and QB at the next level shouldn't you be a starter on the varsity as a junior? And trust me, the basketball competition in that area is awful. Much, much worse than the football which is good but not great (not like California or Florida in terms of athleticism). Now I realize I could be reaching on the basketball thing and that's probably me just being more of just me relating to my own experiences in that area.
Anyways just my take. I realize it's negative, but I don't think this is a five star type of talent.
- This post is for members of BlueandGold only. Join now! 30-Day Free Trial
5-Time POTW Winner, 4 time at BGI and 1 at 24/7
-
mgormal1 said...
I've actually taken some heat for posting this over on II, but I've seen the kid play several sports over the years. I think his ranking is too high. The league he plays in often gets confused with Don Bosco, Bergen Catholic, St Joes', etc because they are close to each other but the league is nowhere near that caliber and they definitely don't play the big boys and the good parachials. I know, cause I played in it. Good football, good coaches, but rarely does it produce d-1 talent. He is definitely a d-1 talent but he isn't playing against other d-1 talent.
Two, as a QB, this the project of all projects. I realize this comes off as overly negative but I really cannot see how he could play QB in college at any place other than GTECH. It would have to be some dramatic metamorphosis in terms of mechanics, arm strength, understanding of defenses. He has none of those things even close to being a college QB right now. I've seen people compare him to Golson, in terms of being a QB they couldn't be further apart.
Another thing I didn't like is that he wasn't a varsity basketball player last year. He spent time on the JV, and really didn't impress there. I mean if you are a legit D-1 athlete that can play corner, safety, and QB at the next level shouldn't you be a starter on the varsity as a junior? And trust me, the basketball competition in that area is awful. Much, much worse than the football which is good but not great (not like California or Florida in terms of athleticism). Now I realize I could be reaching on the basketball thing and that's probably me just being more of just me relating to my own experiences in that area.
Anyways just my take. I realize it's negative, but I don't think this is a five star type of talent.
My luck with the Irish: 2-4, 3-time POTW
- This post is for members of BlueandGold only. Join now! 30-Day Free Trial
PBeuerlein ●
- 5 stars Rating: 93
1006 votes total - (2710)
- 30 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
FGCU_IRISH_FAN
- 5 stars Rating: 91
246 votes total - (769)
- 20 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
mgormal1 said...
I've actually taken some heat for posting this over on II, but I've seen the kid play several sports over the years. I think his ranking is too high. The league he plays in often gets confused with Don Bosco, Bergen Catholic, St Joes', etc because they are close to each other but the league is nowhere near that caliber and they definitely don't play the big boys and the good parachials. I know, cause I played in it. Good football, good coaches, but rarely does it produce d-1 talent. He is definitely a d-1 talent but he isn't playing against other d-1 talent.
Two, as a QB, this the project of all projects. I realize this comes off as overly negative but I really cannot see how he could play QB in college at any place other than GTECH. It would have to be some dramatic metamorphosis in terms of mechanics, arm strength, understanding of defenses. He has none of those things even close to being a college QB right now. I've seen people compare him to Golson, in terms of being a QB they couldn't be further apart.
Another thing I didn't like is that he wasn't a varsity basketball player last year. He spent time on the JV, and really didn't impress there. I mean if you are a legit D-1 athlete that can play corner, safety, and QB at the next level shouldn't you be a starter on the varsity as a junior? And trust me, the basketball competition in that area is awful. Much, much worse than the football which is good but not great (not like California or Florida in terms of athleticism). Now I realize I could be reaching on the basketball thing and that's probably me just being more of just me relating to my own experiences in that area.
Anyways just my take. I realize it's negative, but I don't think this is a five star type of talent.
HamOnWry22 ●
- 5 stars Rating: 94
3382 votes total - (5296)
- 30 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
NDGuyinFL said...
Unbelievable breakaway speed.. I don't care who he is playing against, he's special. I can guarantee his level of competition isn't weaker than DGB's.
He's not bad.. Throws a decent ball on the run. Much better than I was expecting. Already better than Robinson and Tebow's quackers.
- This post is for members of BlueandGold only. Join now! 30-Day Free Trial
5-Time POTW Winner, 4 time at BGI and 1 at 24/7
-
Coach_Clancy
- 4 stars Rating: 65
712 votes total - (1757)
- 29 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
nbennyboy said...
Was wondering what he was as a qb based on people's comments. Then thank you NDGuy for posting the highlights. Absolutely bring this guy in. Who knows where he ends up, position wise. And I do not care, as many have already said we need to upgrade this teams athleticism and this player does that.
I do appreciate mgormal1's insight into the conference, always nice to have some perspective. I am not worried though as I do not expect this young man to finish as a qb here at ND. And I only say that because, if no Kiel which I am still hoping for, I have faith in Hendrix and have alot of excitement about what Golson can become, his highlightes as a qb were awesome. He is a true passer that can move.
I have been wrong many times in the past but lets just get him in here and all pat each other on the back as the national media begins to mention ND's young speed and athleticism (Darby, Tee, Greenberry, Ferguson, Barratti, Brown then hope Fuller, Neal, Westkamp and who knows who else joins.) Not including last years haul: Daniels, Fairley, Attckinson bros, Brown (who has been raved about- my dark horse for next years defensive backfield), McDaniel and Hardy (who is going to be a stud once healthy).
- Post a New Topic
- Back to Topics
- « Previous Topic
- Next Topic »
- Boards ▾
- Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4











Notre Dame back in mix for five-star Devin Fuller